You Can’t Take It with You – Cast, Characters & Production History

“You Can’t Take It with You” is one of the most beloved comedies in the history of American theatre. Written by George S. Kaufman and Moss Hart, this Pulitzer Prize-winning play has been performed continuously since its Broadway premiere on December 14, 1936. The comedy ran for an impressive 838 performances during its original run and has never left the spotlight.

“The way to live and be happy is just to go ahead and live, and not pay attention to the world.”

– George S. Kaufman, in a letter to his wife describing the play’s central idea

Fun Fact: The Educational Theatre Association reports that “You Can’t Take It with You” has appeared on their survey of most-produced high school plays in 80 of the 81 years the survey has been conducted – the most consistent record of any American play.

Complete Character & Cast Guide

Chaotic warm living room set of You Can't Take It with You, 1930s American domestic interior with typewriter, xylophone, and fireworks equipment scattered around

The Sycamore-Vanderhof Family

CharacterDescriptionNotable Performers
Grandpa Martin VanderhofPatriarch who quit Wall Street 35 years ago to collect stamps and attend commencement speechesHenry Travers (1936), Jason Robards (1983), James Earl Jones (2014)
Penelope (Penny) SycamoreAlice’s mother – playwright, painter, writes plays because a typewriter was delivered by mistakeJosephine Hull (1936), Elizabeth Wilson (1983), Kristine Nielsen (2014)
Paul SycamoreAlice’s father – builds fireworks in the basement with Mr. De PinnaFrank Wilcox (1936), Mark Linn-Baker (2014)
Alice SycamoreThe only “normal” family member, stenographer at Kirby & Co.Margot Stevenson (1936), Rose Byrne (2014), Jean Arthur (1938 film)
Essie CarmichaelAlice’s sister – aspiring ballerina, candy maker, married to EdPaula Trueman (1936), Annaleigh Ashford (2014, Tony Award winner)
Ed CarmichaelEssie’s husband – xylophone player, amateur printerGeorge Heller (1936), Will Brill (2014)

The Kirby Family & Others

CharacterDescriptionNotable Performers
Tony KirbyVP at his father’s company, in love with AliceJess Barker (1936), Fran Kranz (2014), James Stewart (1938 film)
Mr. Anthony KirbyTony’s wealthy, conservative Wall Street fatherWilliam J. Kelly (1936), Byron Jennings (2014), Edward Arnold (film)
Mrs. KirbyTony’s equally conservative motherVirginia Hammond (1936), Johanna Day (2014)
Boris KolenkhovEssie’s flamboyant Russian ballet teacher – major comic roleGeorge Tobias (1936), James Coco (1983), Reg Rogers (2014)
Mr. De PinnaDelivery man who moved in years ago and never leftFrank Conlan (1936), Patrick Kerr (2014)
Grand Duchess OlgaFormer Russian aristocrat, now a waitress at Childs’Mitzi Hajos (1936), Elizabeth Ashley (2014)
Rheba & DonaldThe family’s housekeeper and her boyfriendRuth Attaway & Oscar Polk (1936), Crystal Dickinson & Marc Damon Johnson (2014)

Fun Fact: In the original production, the character of Penny Sycamore became a playwright purely because a typewriter was delivered to the house by mistake years earlier. Kaufman and Hart drew from their own family eccentricities to create the Vanderhof clan.

Broadway Production History

YearVenueDirectorKey CastPerformances
1936-1938Booth / Imperial / AmbassadorGeorge S. KaufmanHenry Travers, Josephine Hull838
1965-1966Lyceum Theatre (APA-Phoenix)Ellis RabbDonald Moffat, Rosemary Harris250+ (repertory)
1983-1984Plymouth / Royale TheatreEllis RabbJason Robards, Colleen Dewhurst, James Coco312
2014-2015Longacre TheaterScott EllisJames Earl Jones, Rose Byrne, Annaleigh AshfordFull run

“You Can’t Take It With You is one of the most persuasive works of pure escapism in Broadway history.”

– The New York Times

The 1938 Film Adaptation

Frank Capra directed the film adaptation, which won two Academy Awards – Best Picture and Best Director. This was Capra’s third Best Director Oscar in five years, following “It Happened One Night” (1934) and “Mr. Deeds Goes to Town” (1936).

Film Cast Highlights

  • James Stewart as Tony Kirby – cast after Capra saw him in “Navy Blue and Gold”
  • Jean Arthur as Alice Sycamore – one of the era’s top leading ladies
  • Lionel Barrymore as Grandpa Vanderhof – his arthritis was written into the script as a banister-sliding injury
  • Ann Miller as Essie – reportedly only 15 years old during filming
  • Edward Arnold as Mr. Kirby – his role was expanded with a real estate subplot

Fun Fact: Columbia Pictures purchased the film rights for $200,000 – a record-setting price at the time, equivalent to roughly $4.3 million in 2025 dollars. The film was the fourth-highest grossing picture of 1938.

Why Community Theatres Love This Play

Practical Advantages

  • Large ensemble cast (9M, 7W + extras) – provides roles for performers of varying experience
  • Single-set design – the Vanderhof living room, reducing technical complexity
  • Flexible casting – Dramatists Play Service offers an alternate version for diverse casting
  • Family-friendly content – suitable for all audiences, no controversial material
  • Proven audience appeal – consistently fills seats for 88+ years

Community Theatre in Winnipeg

Winnipeg, Manitoba, boasts an unusually vibrant community theatre ecosystem. Companies such as Hood and Dagger Productions (which donated over $14,900 to partner charities in its first two years), Dry Cold Productions, 7 Ages Productions (25+ years active), and The Dramatic Theatre Company all maintain active seasons.

The Winnipeg Mennonite Theatre, which operated for over 50 years before concluding its activities in 2023, regularly staged classics like “You Can’t Take It with You.” The Mennonite tradition of volunteer-driven community performance – rooted in church youth group theatricals dating back to the 1930s – created a natural affinity for ensemble comedies celebrating family and community values.

The Association of Community Theatres of Manitoba (ACT Manitoba) supports local companies with script search tools, educational workshops, and the annual ACT Festival.

Mennonite Comedians and Performing Arts Heritage

Community theatre has deep roots in Mennonite culture, particularly in Manitoba, where Mennonite youth societies (Jugendvereine) organized plays and dramatic readings as early as the 1930s. This tradition of performance within a close-knit community has produced not just theatre companies, but also comedians and entertainers with Mennonite backgrounds who bring a distinctive perspective to comedic performance.

The emphasis on storytelling, self-deprecating humour, community engagement, and the ability to find comedy in everyday life – values deeply embedded in Mennonite community experience – translates naturally to the theatrical stage. The intersection of Mennonite heritage and comedy remains an often-overlooked yet richly rewarding chapter in Canadian cultural history.

“All the talented participants in WMT’s works volunteer their considerable gifts towards these productions and for our audience.”

– Winnipeg Mennonite Theatre, from its About page (archived)

Quick Reference: Casting

Role TypeCharactersCasting Notes
Leading roles (3)Grandpa, Alice, TonyAnchor the show – need warmth, comic timing, romantic chemistry
Major supporting (5)Penny, Paul, Essie, Ed, KolenkhovStrong comedy skills required, especially Kolenkhov and Penny
Featured (4-6)Mr./Mrs. Kirby, De Pinna, Rheba, Donald, OlgaCharacter actors – each gets showcase moments
Smaller roles (3-5)Henderson, FBI agents, WilburGood for newer performers; some doubling possible

Performance rights: Dramatists Play Service (amateur) | Concord Theatricals (professional).